Apostrophes or No Apostrophes that is the question

Discussion in 'The Lounge' started by DavidGP, Feb 2, 2014.

  1. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Apostrophes or No Apostrophes that is the question, well it is a hot topic for Sunday in the UK this weekend.

    http://news.sky.com/story/1205040/councils-criticised-for-dropping-apostrophes

    The quote above from the story is exactly my thoughts on this subject and while I know I may not always punctuate in the forum posts all the time, it is not teaching our kid's the right message, for example a teacher hammer's home the message to punctuate and then little Johnny (fictitious person) say's to mommy on the way home from school, "why does that road sign not have punctuation"... what do you say!

    But then again we do have kids doing text, twitter, getto gansta, l33t speak, is the English or any language being swamped up with lazy-*** typing?

    I've seen bad articles in the press with poor use of language and sentences etc.

    No word of a lie I have seen document's in work typed in twitter lingo as if Outlook Email forced you to only use 140 Characters.



    Thoughts on do we teach and educate properly or just start teaching modern social networking speak?




    *disclaimer --- maybe the odd wrong full stop use above*
     
  2. solaris89

    solaris89 First Sergeant

    You do realize you have 2 incorrect uses of apostrophes in your post? :-D

    At work, everything seems to either spelled wrong or punctuated wrong when 99% of what you deal with are acronyms. ;)

    Hi David, long time no chat. I'm at Chris' house right now, he said to say hello. :)

    (By the way, that apostrophe next to Chris name is correct. :-D )
     
  3. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    I do or did Chris get you to say that? mmmmmm ;)

    Yeah I get the acronym thing as medical lingo is like your space stuff.

    Yes indeed long time no chat, Angie hope you, Chris and Teresa are all ok?
     
  4. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    Personally I think the school system in the USA has got to lenient letting kids turn in homework using abbreviated words. Having to write the full word helps learn the correct spelling, but of course I am of the generation with no spell check, we actually had to look it up in the dictionary.;) Only problem with that is if you did not already kind of know the spelling you could not find it in the dictionary. :confused Now you get suggestions of what the word you are trying to spell.:-o
    I guess my thought is how are they going to be able to read if they can't spell or how will they be able to spell whole words if they are allowed to abbreviate all words?
    Sometimes I read a text message and go huh! Sorry I got off on a rant about chat lingo and forgot about apostrophes.:-D
     
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2014
  5. solaris89

    solaris89 First Sergeant

    I can honestly attribute three-quarters of my smart-a$$ness as a direct result of working for him :-D

    In other words, it was him...


    Yeah, they're fine. He's got a lot going on with NASA and the US Navy, and she's busy spending the money he earns :-D
     
  6. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    If I use Yahoo Messenger to send a SMS to someone's cell phone and I use an apostrophe it will show the word with the apostrophe when I type it but when I hit Send the message box will show several symbols in the place of the apostrophe. Seems Yahoo Messenger does not use or allow apostrophes now.
     
  7. Fred_G

    Fred_G Heat packin' geek

    Personally, I think it is very bad to use abbreviated text in school, or to allow it in published work. I very often see horribly abused language in headlines and online articles.

    Abbreviations are fine on signs if they need it, but 'official signage' and anything for school should be in the official language. Do your text on your own time.

    Teach the kids to effectively communicate.
     
  8. oma

    oma MajorGeek

    I see often the word *your* instead of *you're*. That was not how I was taught English in High School. For example, your book is correct, but not *your* glad. Were we taught wrong 55+ years ago?
     
  9. Fred_G

    Fred_G Heat packin' geek

    Thought the your was possessive, and the you're was you are. Been a while since I took English....
     
  10. Kestrel13!

    Kestrel13! Super Malware Fighter - Major Dilemma Staff Member

    I think there's actually 4 LOL *Runs and hides*
     
  11. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    Soon those trying to teach English Class will not know how because they never learned it. Same goes for math and use of calculators in class instead of learning how to do it with pen and paper. :(
     
    Last edited: Feb 3, 2014
  12. Gensuknives

    Gensuknives Grand pooty-meister

    And, heaven forbid any mention of a slide rule!!!!!!!!!
     
  13. Rikky

    Rikky Wile E. Coyote - One of a kind

    The English language is stoopid anyhoo??????!!!!!,,,::::

    W,e should all GO Fr' "ee" 'Styl'ee ...!!!

    :-D

    I cannot comment on other people's punctuation, my epitaph will be punctuated wrong.
     
  14. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    ;)And the generation gap grows even wider because the generations don't speak the same language.:confused
     
  15. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    We were not allowed to use the slide rule until we knew how to do multiplication and division on paper.
     
  16. oma

    oma MajorGeek

    I see 3 incorrect uses of apostrophes or is it me? :confused May well have been done on purpose. :-D
     
  17. Caliban

    Caliban I don't need no steenkin' title!

    As the son of English teachers and as the husband of an English teacher I have to jump in:

    ***

    teaching our kid's - should be kids (plural of the noun kid)

    hammer's home - should be hammers (present tense of the verb hammer)

    say's to mommy - should be says (present tense of the verb say)

    I have seen document's in work - should be documents (plural of the noun document)

    ***

    Sorry - couldn't resist. ;)
     
  18. oma

    oma MajorGeek

    Oh Caliban, you are right. I missed the last one: document's, that should be documents. Thanks for setting us straight. :)
     
    Last edited: Feb 3, 2014
  19. Rikky

    Rikky Wile E. Coyote - One of a kind

    Is that statement or a question old timer?:-D
     
  20. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    Statement! Oops my age must be showing.
    I see I better freshen up on proper English now that the Rikky and Caliban are watching.:-D
    I was not the best student because my mind tends to wander off over there >>>>>>>>>>>>>>:-o Still some of it managed to seep in, although I have forgotten most of it.rolleyes
     
  21. Rikky

    Rikky Wile E. Coyote - One of a kind

    Sorry if I've given the impression I cared, I was aiming for the opposite.:cool

    I read the words so fast my brain hasn't got time to worry about punctuation, if I'm not reading fast then I'm not reading because it isn't interesting enough.

    Writing technical paper for work or school is a totally different ball game when compared to forum posting though, spending any time going over posts punctuating them when only about 50-100 people will ever read and even fewer will care is a waste of precious life IMO.

    Capitals, periods, comma's in roughly the right place I consider fine for forum posts, being too lazy shift on the 'I' or not putting a period at the end when writing something like, "i went to the shops" Is where I draw the line and I'll say something.
     
  22. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    OK noted, Rikky does not care.
    Anyway, back to the reason I posted on this topic in the first place, my theory is English should be taught in case it is later needed for something necessary like employment. ;) Having said that I admit I don't always speak or write it correctly. But even I realize it as soon as the words are out of my mouth or after I have typed it and hit post.
     
  23. solaris89

    solaris89 First Sergeant

    So we are all in agreement; David started a thread on the use of apostrophes and has no idea how to use them. :-D
     
  24. Fred_G

    Fred_G Heat packin' geek

    Apostrophes? We don't need no stinking apostrophes...

    :-D
     
  25. Rikky

    Rikky Wile E. Coyote - One of a kind

    roflmao
     
  26. dyamond

    dyamond Imelda Marcos of Majorgeeks

    I think it's actually really sad in this age that many, many people can't form a simple grammatically correct sentence.

    No, I'm not talking about an accidental misuse of an ' or using your instead of you're (I know I've done it, especially because I type fast and sometimes my fingers are faster than my brain :-D ). I'm talking about constant misuse or even lack of understanding that they ARE different words.

    I watch people write things on facebook, blogs, or commenting on articles and it's really astounding how little people actually know or even care. I've (lately) been told that I use too many big words when I speak, which is kind of sad because they aren't even big words.

    I use abbreviations when I text but I still write full sentence if and when I need to, it's a real tragedy that to some people there is no difference. That's why I think that they should continue to teach real grammar because you can't get a job with text, l33t, or whatever else kind of speech that's "in" right now.
     
  27. Fred_G

    Fred_G Heat packin' geek

    Amen.

    I do my best not to criticize basic errors. But, if all you know is l33t, how are you going to write a report, or deal with anything technical. You have to have a standard to work from.

    I often take the time to use punctuation and proper capitalization when sending a text, just cause.
     
  28. Caliban

    Caliban I don't need no steenkin' title!

    My apologies David - I did not address the following:

    IMO we should continue to teach and educate properly in all classical areas (language/grammar, literature, histories, art, sciences, humanities, etc.) - it's up to the students whether they wish to learn or not. The new social media phenomenon, however, seems to require a more fluid approach to education in general. I think most current curriculum mandates have not been able to keep up with the modern language flux.

    I've been around education my whole life, been teaching my entire adult life - there is nothing more satisfying than seeing that light bulb come on in a student's head. I've also never learned more than when presented with a fresh perspective about a problem from a bright mind.

    Now people have so many more 'teaching' inputs - the media are the teachers whether they're right or wrong. :(
     
  29. Anon-9aee479f8f

    Anon-9aee479f8f Anonymized

    A English teacher that taught at the local school wrote a book. I thought it might be interesting to read the book written by this teacher because it was suppose to be about growing up in the area. I was surprised and disappointed to find grammar mistakes in the book in several places and a portion of one chapter was in the book twice. It was a self-published book so no editor or publishing house proofreading but keep in mine it was written by a English teacher. It is my understanding the teacher and at least one other person proofread the book before sending it off to be printed. It just shocked me the mistakes were missed.
     
  30. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Knew it!!!

    but I bet working with Chris is a hoot!

    LMAO... on Teresa spending! but I know what you and Chris are going through with various projects and the time they take up as I'm diversifying from my normal research into Malarial Retinopathy (two of the authors are my bosses)

    Jen I think you have hit the nail on the head, in that some punctuation errors are going to happen and I did do a few in my original post, but its the larger picture and I see folk that have not checked their Resume for errors and apply for jobs with really bad spelling and punctuation. The really bad thing I see is no sentences and spaces, some type everything in one block, nightmare to read.

    or does he!?

    likely not but the discussion is needed, are they an importance to real life or not.. I think proper grammar is needed, too much these days we are going towards twitter-speak.
     

MajorGeeks.Com Menu

Downloads All In One Tweaks \ Android \ Anti-Malware \ Anti-Virus \ Appearance \ Backup \ Browsers \ CD\DVD\Blu-Ray \ Covert Ops \ Drive Utilities \ Drivers \ Graphics \ Internet Tools \ Multimedia \ Networking \ Office Tools \ PC Games \ System Tools \ Mac/Apple/Ipad Downloads

Other News: Top Downloads \ News (Tech) \ Off Base (Other Websites News) \ Way Off Base (Offbeat Stories and Pics)

Social: Facebook \ YouTube \ Twitter \ Tumblr \ Pintrest \ RSS Feeds