smart phone

Discussion in 'Software' started by peterr, Jul 29, 2010.

  1. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    Can someone who is content with their smart phone and carrier please help me pick out both. I need about 700 minutes of talking, no need for text, and want unlimited web for myself + my wife.
    I was going to get a Windows phone but found out there were hardly any apps.
    I would like the tethering idea that came with the T Moblile Windows phone for my laptop but am turned off because of the lack of applications.
    I want to easily synch to my desktop so documents I create can be transferred to My Docs in the pc.
    The T mobile Android plan for family seems to be about: Plan =$60, web for both $60, insurance $6 and taxes about $25 = ?$150.
    I have really been trying to "look before I leap" but there are so many variables it is difficult.
    Could someone help me out?
     
  2. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi Peter

    I dont know too much on US data plans for web access but majority if not all in the UK are now capped, I'm lucky my contract is an older one and still get unlimited web until I re-new, then its 500mb per month.

    But if T-mobile in the USA is same as UK then while they say unlimited it is very much capped and you pay a premium fo rgowing over so may very sure its unlimited, but to be honest unless your streaming media its not easy to hit the caps.

    I have done the "apps" thing with my iPhone and it gets boring after a while, but I know that the "apps" for Android phones are growing all the time, for Windows Mobile phones, their are apps, but not as many in one easy place (Windows Marketplace), you have to search the net for websites that collect them just like Majorgeeks collects good software for Windows PCs.

    I while I still have an iphone, I now use a Windows Mobile phone (a HTC HD2) for a few reasons, one it tethers to my laptop or netbook, without any new payment plans, which the iphone needs, to the fact that it I can download free Microsoft Office 2010 Mobile, so my Outlook is sync'd as well as I can deal with Word, Excel, Powerpoint and OneNote and SharePoint Workspace.

    If you want a very easy to use phone with loads of apps, go iPhone (dunno about the iphone 4 tho, due to its signal issues) but definatly the 3GS, if you want a new bread of phone that will offer many apps (and will have a free app creator soon, I did post a link in another thread here the other day) then Android is a winner.

    But if you want a great link between Windows and the Phone, plus Office apps, then Windows Mobile, although I would make sure it can be updates to Windows Mobile 7.0 software when released as thats due soon.
     
  3. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    I dont know too much on US data plans for web access but majority if not all in the UK are now capped, I'm lucky my contract is an older one and still get unlimited web until I re-new, then its 500mb per month.

    >>I read the fine print on the back of the T mobile and it said unlimited plans may incur a charge if the use is excessive.
    I think the whole world is playing with words and contracts are to be broken. When I was working unlimited had one definition.
    I do understand that caps are hard to reach.

    >>"apps" for Android phones are growing
    Yes my brother had a Droid and has tons of apps. I now understand that Windows marketplace is quite limited compared with iphone and Droid. if you are an app person it is a factor.

    >>one it tethers to my laptop or netbook,
    I had tethering explained to me and really like the idea. I was unclear whether tethering was enabled by the Widows phone or T Mobile. I seriously want tethering and would be a factor in my choice. Could you tell me what enables this feature so I can narrow my selection. You seemed to imply Windows phone allowed for the tethering but I would like to be sure.

    >I don't hear too many bad things about the Droid and hope it can Tether with a carrier. T Mobile seems quite popular here.
    I was told Droid is a Verizon item but it seems the Android os exists on other phones -true?.

    >>Except for apps, Windows Phone with Windpws 7 sounds like a good way to go.
    Most of my time is on the pc now but that may change with the right smart phone.

    Thank you for helping me pare down the variables.
     
  4. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    I agree with you, unlimited should mean just that, but as you say they are playing on words and hoping that the average user is not going to hit the caps, thus unlimited!

    Yes Markeyplace is limited, but its a relitively new idea for Microsoft in this area to have an all in one area, yep they like Google nicked it from Apple's Apps Store, but I can imagine over time the apps will increase, personally if you are more going for apps then Apple or Droid are the way to go but websites like this do list many good apps for WinMo HERE and HERE as examples (sadly not all under as Apple are one roof)

    For me it was the phone as no interaction from the carrier, unless they enabled it by default for Windows Mobile phones, I just no that they do not have it enabled for iPhones (you have to pay an extra £5 a month on top of your contract, whereas I do not), would need to check with your carrier this to be 100%

    But a quick test of my connection via HSDPA and I get around 1.5mb/s +/- .5mb/s depending on signal strenght, so download speeds good enough for mobile internet.


    Me nether in its version 2.0+ OS its very good, Verizon is just the carrier, you can get many different phones with the Droid OS on...

    HTC HERE
    Sony Ericsson HERE (I do like this one)
    Sansung HERE

    just a sample, the three above have more Android based phones than those.

    >>Except for apps, Windows Phone with Windpws 7 sounds like a good way to go.
    Most of my time is on the pc now but that may change with the right smart phone.

    Thank you for helping me pare down the variables.[/QUOTE]

    More info on Windows Mobile 7 HERE
     
  5. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    Great information, Halo.
    When you shop for apps for Win moph, do you look for just Windows apps?
    Is there a charge for Win apps and for other apps?
    I thought the TMobile person led me astray but perhaps the Windows HTC-HD2 is a good idea.
     
  6. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi Peter

    Yes Windows Mobile (WinMo) apps are no different to Apple and some free and some paid, to be honest WinMo has more paid apps that free, unless you look for the free!

    I personally love the HTC HD2 and its the one I use now as my daily phone, but yes I do also have an iPhone 3G, the HTC HD2 has the edge for me due to better GPS, better HSDPA, better Office compatability, better sync compatability with Outlook, and can easily be used as a storage device as it uses micro SD cards, so add a 16GB mSD card and you have storage of an iPhone, and use multiple ones you can have a media card for video and audio and one for data, cannot do that with an iPhone.


    If as I said you want ease of use and apps, cannot beat the iPhone, or Android, but dont count out the WinMo phones because of lack of apps, they do make up for this if your a business user....

    I would go into a shop and have a play of the HTC HD2, its huge but the screen is great for video! iPhone or Android dont come close for screen size/quality.
     
  7. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    Halo
    The screen is great indeed. I read they had to patch a few things but what's new - hey?
    I also read Win 7 is due out 4th qtr so worth waiting; unless out now?
    Thanx for all the tips and am leaning towards Windows 7 when available.
    Price at store for phone was high @ $238 for two as I saw you can get from a distribitor for a lot less. I do not know what they consider a distributor as I have only seen retail. Will Bing it and see what's up.
    Peter
     
  8. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi Peter

    Yeah all phones need patches sadly but thats the nature of technology these days, rush it out the door and patch it later.

    No Windows 7 mobile is not out yet, indeed should be mid to back end 4th Qtr, so the rumours say. If you want something thats like a Windows based PC then Windows Mobile is good, however must restate the other two are better for apps, not that I miss the apps too much, have found most of the ones I like, also on mine have a very good GPS navigation app (Co-Pilot) as the GPS on the HTC is far superiour to that on my iPhone (dont know how good the iPhone 4 is tho).

    Do look at what apps you think you would like and see if Apple, Android or Windows offers those, this may help you make up your mind more.
     
  9. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    I received a note from a friend just now;

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Mobile
    QUOTE
    http://www.technewsworld.com/story/Microso...?wlc=1280525688
    Windows Phone 7 is scheduled for launch around the end of the year, and it could well miss the holiday sales season. Even if Microsoft manages to launch Windows 7 smart phones in time for holiday season sales, that might not do it much good.

    "Microsoft's going to be a competitor, but possibly not out of the gate," Al Hilwa, a research director at IDC, told TechNewsWorld. "It may take a refinement or two after that to be in the same league as some of the other players."

    I do not get all of it but it sounds disheartenting for Win moph.
    Do you think the HTC-HD has the hardware to upgrade to Win 7 or is it too soon to tell becdause it has not yet been released.
    I wold not want to buy then be sorry that I could not upgrade Does the upgrade cost?
    I was also wondering if tethering was a carrier or phone factor? I guess both in that the carrier must allow it and the phone and pc must be compatible;please correct me.
    Btw,
    I did see the gps on the Win moph and it said something like .......finder.
    Talk soon
     
  10. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi

    the HTC HD2 is debatable, it has the hardware but as things are changing in WinMo7 all the time, it may not have the newer graphics gpu capabilities to be upgradable, sadly I cannot get my hands on the beta of WinMo7 or I would have tried it on mine.

    Personally looking at Android based phones, the Xperia looks a good option or one of the HTC Android based phones.
     
  11. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek


    >>You did say that you could sync and work Android phones with your Windows pc -correct?
    You like the Android o.s. I gather or is it a combination of an Android phone + Android O.S
    I know my jargon is rudimentary but forums are my classroom.
    I have read up on the HTC company and they seem to be quite stable.
    Is it correct to say that HTC is like saying Motorola or another brand?
     
  12. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi Peter

    I know only that HTC Android phones are ok with Windows as HTC have a sync app HERE, sadly I have not had an Android phone for long enough to play with at home to test the sync capabilities I'm afraid, maybe one of our Android users will jump in on this.


    yes HTC is like saying Motorola, they are a huge company that used to make phones for many other makers, but decided to release their own brand phones, under their own name and I'm really impressed with mine, build quality is superb.


    This is what Windows Mobile Phones use to connect and sync, Windows Mobile Device Centre and HERE at Wikipedia so info.


    For syncing a phone, iTunes really has it nailed in one app, for ease of use, iPhones are king upto now.

    But would guess your thoughts are more between Android and WinMo?
     
  13. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    I understand about brand names now.
    Are we excluding iphones because of cost or incompatibility with the Win pc?
    Coordinating; tethering, syncing with Windows pcs, and all is quite tricky.
    I read about the app sync and there was no mention of Word documents.
    I'm afraid I'll have a few blushing moments before I am through.
    I think I read you can sync Android to Win pc with an app.
    Tethering is a big factor in my persuit and I know the HTC -HD2 does tether with T mobile.
    I guess tethering is a company not a phone issue.
    The iphone is Mac right? If so you would think it might not work well with Windows because with pcs thay are different worlds.
    I'm curious, does your carrier allow free tethering?
    As I understand it, I can use it to get the web while traveling by using a usb cable with the phone and the laptop. Sure beats an online card I would have to purchase.
     
  14. DavidGP

    DavidGP MajorGeeks Forum Administrator - Grand Pooh-Bah Staff Member

    Hi Peter

    I wouldn't exclude the iPhone as it syncs with Windows via iTunes very well, you can get apps for most jobs, don't off hand know about MS Office tho, but it will sync with Outlook fine, Microsoft have just released a free online version of Office so that is an alternative on any Internet enabled phone.

    Yes iPhone is an apple devices but works on a mac or windows computer ok, as mentioned I do also have an iPhone.

    The plus point also for me in the HTC and WinMo was u can use it also as a big USB storage device as you use microSD cards in it to add storage do can have multiple different ones with different data on them, unlike the iPhone in that you are restricted to the storage it has as it's not expandable.

    Yes with the HTC HD2 my carrier O2 does include tethering via this phone, they do not with the iPhone (don't know on Android phones off hand), as I use it a fair amount when out and about, use it with a netbook, works very well.

    The iPhone will tether but for my carrier it's an extra cost on your monthly £5 iirc, whereas the HD2 is as mentioned included, yes exactly as you mentioned I just use the supplied USB cable and plug into netbook and choose Internet and once the network has loaded on the netbook I'm off and driving, takes noire than a few mins to get online and saves having to type on a small phone touch keyboard.
     
  15. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    HI Halo
    Unless I missed it I did not see if Word docs can be synced using iphone or Android.
    Isn't the free tethering great!
    I am recoding this information and I thank you
     
  16. Mimsy

    Mimsy Superior Imperial Queen of the MG Games Forum

    Sorry for hopping in late: One of my co-workers tethers his iPhone with a free app he added on. Also, jailbreaking them is legal in the US now, but still voids the warranty. :)
     
  17. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    So he tethers the iphone for free. Is this because of the phone or the carrier?
     
  18. Mimsy

    Mimsy Superior Imperial Queen of the MG Games Forum

    Well, I know he is with AT&T, since his iphone isn't jailbroken, and that he's not paying for tethering. It may be because he's not doing it often, he's a Mac user so syncing with the computer in other ways is really easy for him, and it's possible that if he was doing it more than once or twice a month he'd have to pay.
     
  19. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    So we really do not know whether tethering is a feture of the phone or the carrier or the plan?
    I have a feeling it is the carrier but could be wrong.
    What is jailbreaking;something like hacking?
     
  20. Mimsy

    Mimsy Superior Imperial Queen of the MG Games Forum

    Pretty much. You hack the OS to unlock the iPhone from AT&T, so you can use it with other carriers.
     
  21. Philipp

    Philipp Administrator Staff Member

    It is a feature of the iPhone that carriers can disable tethering in the Mobileconfig on their locked iPhones.
     
  22. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    Aha, a carrier issue - thank you.
     
  23. Snowman269

    Snowman269 Private E-2

    I'm surprised not to see other android users chime in, so I will try. I'll start from the beginning.

    I started with the First Android phone the "HTC - G1", 2 years ago with T-Mobile and have been happy with the system. I was interested in the new snapdragon 1Ghz processors in the Nexus 1 and the HTC EVO with a 4.3" HD screen, but due to speed usability and the balance of the good battery life factor, I upgraded from the G1 to HTC "My Touch 3G Slide" android phone, staying with T-Mobile, also because I had to have an external keyboard.

    I use the phone for work mostly and the phone syncs with Google business Mail, Calendar, Contacts, Maps & Google Talk seamlessly. My #1 favorite app is Google Voice which does a good enough job of translating voicemail to text, the feature saves me a lot of time handling customers. Through the browser I access all my word docs, spreadsheets, etc though Google Docs, which I wish there was a better app, but for now it works. at least I have access.

    I have a 8g microSD card to carry files, which works like a jump drive,

    A good friend has both an IPhone 3gs that he purchased, then his employer supplied him with an Motorola Droid. The phones are very close in operation and function, and he has a hard time deciding on which phone he prefers. Likes the verizon networks and speed, but also like the number of apps available on the iphone, which android is gaining ground.
     
  24. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    I have become accustomed to using Windows so was trying to find a way to sync to my pc.
    I guess most of what you are doing is Google related.
    My only experience with Google was Gmail and I used it briefly then turned to to Windows Live Email.
    I also tried Thunderbird as an email program and had trouble with it so went to Windows Live Mail.
    My naiveté has probably led to this reply sounding like it has not much to do with your message but what I am trying to say is that I have had more success with Windows than Google, Netscape etc.
    I think intelligent versed young workers can handle workarounds and complexities quite easily but older less experienced retirees are looking for less complex systems.
    I need a phone I can easily sync to my pc with, can tether to my laptop and wouldn't mind a few apps but know that Marketplace does not have many.
    I am glad that you are successful with your system and appreciate your input.
    I shall read it over and see what I can extract that will be of benefit.
    Thank you
     
  25. Snowman269

    Snowman269 Private E-2

    I understand, many of my current clients felt exactly the way you do before they started working with myself and my company. First off, I'm not trying to convince you to change, and now that I have stated that, I'll share a little bit of what i am seeing in the marketplace. Change can be a challenge for sure and the're always some trade-offs, since noone offers a perfect system for everyone. That's why if you are happy with what are using, more power to you.

    I was solely an Outlook user until 2007 and also from 2003 to 2007 I utilized a pocket PC using MSActivesync. I was just ok with it when it worked, but it just wasn't robust enough for me, so I patiently searched for another option, but deep inside I really grew to dislike it. I worked with people with blackberries, but it was still dependent on Microsoft exchange servers and that crap I was already sick of.

    Changing over was no fun, learning a new system was a chore, but I could see the strategy Google was building, would be worth the frustration (if it was dependable) and I could eventually learn it.

    Now, that i'm here, I'm not interested in changing again either, heh, heh... or at least not any sooner than I have too.

    Currently, I have over a hundred business customers signed up with Google Business apps and somewhere under a thousand people using Google mail, Docs, etc with many jumping to Android phones or Iphones. So, yeah, I do understand the change factor, Since some people just can't seem to handle the switch. I've found about 2% go back to Outlook, and the rest like the new found freedom and flexibility enough to stay to with new tech.

    Most of my customers are 35 - 55 years young, and those in their 50's are the most stressed about learning new things. They pretty much have to embrace technology, since they plan to work for at least another 15 years before they retire, and the young whipper snappers are eating them up alive because everything has changed around them.

    So for now I hold tech classes to try to help, and my first questions are for those to raise their hand who want help learning how to cut and paste. That's just a quick way to guage what I am dealing with, usually 5 to 10% raise their hand...

    And then there is texting...

    As you can see from this, if you are a retiree, sounds to me like you are doing great! So have a great day and just keep learning!
     
    Last edited: Aug 6, 2010
  26. peterr

    peterr MajorGeek

    I think my conclusions are based upon past experiences.
    Gmail, for example; I created a folder for my "stuff" and occasionally dropped some items of importance there. I was alarmed to find when I clicked the delete button for the message that was in the inbox, it also removed the same files I had saved in my "stuff" box. It did not discern between the two folders but picked up on the same file to delete. I don't know if that has changed. At Windows Live Email I can do the same but the program does what is is told + does not affect two folders.
    Some may be redundant but as I said I had an awful time with Thunderbird and even Google confirmed others, too, had similar issues. The installer is fickle and the means of support is exasperating. It is like speaking to a synthesizer that cannot understand what you are trying to convey to it.
    Windows Live email works with no issues as my email program. Their support is no better, however.
    Your note was well written and I agree that Google is working toward a goal; I feel thaat there are some unfinished issues with their products and they are working on them. In time they will be smoother and easier to work with. I could cite several specific problems with Gmail, Google, Netscape, Thunderbird etc. but I would be digressing.
    I was very interested in your route; I love alternatives but the frustrations along the way have kept me with what works, i.e. M.S. I can hear millions cringing as I type.
    I am always willing to try and will not close the door.
    Although I am not a high level user I do know my way around the pc fairly well.
    Now, the smart phone is another thing. I have not had the opportunity to familiarize myself with one that is why I am looking under rocks before I commit to two years of problems. Seven decades have taught me to look first.
    Another variable is that these smart phones and carrier combos are changing as we speak and not always for the better. I cite the tethering issue with ATT.
    I know I will find what I have indicated in this thread and appreciate all the input I can find, such as yours.
    Tether, ez sync to pc, no use for Outlook, Word only, sufficient talk with little text, voice, apps are a problem as you have insufficient with Windows and thousands with iphone and Android, unlimited web-without small print saying that unlimited is not really unlimited in that if you use too much you are charged.
    I have work to do in this regard ; I hope I have not bored you and that we both benefited from this exchange, I know that I did.
    I hope others jump in with suggestions to help develop the package I am looking for.
    Thank you
     

MajorGeeks.Com Menu

Downloads All In One Tweaks \ Android \ Anti-Malware \ Anti-Virus \ Appearance \ Backup \ Browsers \ CD\DVD\Blu-Ray \ Covert Ops \ Drive Utilities \ Drivers \ Graphics \ Internet Tools \ Multimedia \ Networking \ Office Tools \ PC Games \ System Tools \ Mac/Apple/Ipad Downloads

Other News: Top Downloads \ News (Tech) \ Off Base (Other Websites News) \ Way Off Base (Offbeat Stories and Pics)

Social: Facebook \ YouTube \ Twitter \ Tumblr \ Pintrest \ RSS Feeds